Check out the most popular Home Insurance agencies & companies in Pickaway County, OH & compare the best quotes from them.

Get Quotes From The Best & Compare

Top Home Insurance Companies in Pickaway County, OH

Home Insurance Company A.M. Best Financial Strength Rating Homeowners Insurance Market share
State Farm A 20.9%
Allstate A+ 10.89%
Liberty Mutual A 8.64%
Nationwide A+ 7.28%
GEICO A++ 3.2%

Top Liberty Mutual Home Insurance Agents in Pickaway County, OH

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
Marvin Somoza 341 Norton Rd
43228-1730
(614) 870-1149
Todd D Greenwalt Lutcf 150 E Mound St Ste 202
43215
Oscar Quintana 1600 W LANE AVE STE 200
43221
614-453-4400
Yolanda Munoz Lutcf 511 Main St
43125
Justin Jemela 500 S FOURTH ST
43206
614-228-4496
Steven Gryglik 32 W Franklin St
45764
John P Mccombs Lutcf 96 E 4TH ST
45601
740-773-1620
Sunny Singh 111 W Johnstown Rd
43230
Thomas Bell 5880 Venture Dr
43017
Steven Nicoletti 216 Pearl Street
45640

Top Nationwide Home Insurance Agents in Pickaway County, OH

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
Mark R Partner 205 S Main St
43160
(740) 335-3232
Marsh Insurance & Financial Inc. 608 Forest Rose Ave
43130
(740) 653-1091
Kenneth Ray Henry 39 WEST WINTER ST STE 207
43015
740-369-1040
Kenneth Rhodes And Associates Inc. 9932 BREWSTER LN
43065
614-764-0121
Marsh Insurance & Financial Inc. 303 N 21st St
43055-4201
(740) 345-9574
Michael A Burke 4942 Reed Rd
43220
(614) 545-1516
Kenneth Rhodes And Associates Inc. 441 VILLAGE PARK DRIVE
43065
614-433-9930
Comparable Insurance Agency Inc. 5290 Central College Rd
43081-9571
614-882-FARM
H.P. Lucas Inc. 51 N Sandusky St
43015
(740) 369-2886
Jim Johnson Insurance Agency Inc. 414 E MAIN STREET
43130
740-653-8623

Top State Farm Home Insurance Agents in Pickaway County, OH

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
Tyler Evans 4 W Main St Ste 600
45502
Al Chen 266 E Locust St
www.alchensf.com 45177-2375
937-382-4789
Kurt Hawley 38 E CHERRY STREET
www.kurthawley.com 43074
740-362-5601
Tammy Felton 345 E Main St
www.tammyfelton.com 43130
Rhonda Greathouse 3440 S Hamilton Rd
www.rhondagreathouse.net 43232
(614) 864-3882
Jac Clutter Po Box 1207
43017
Kenneth Ramsey 475 PENNSYLVANIA AVE
43015
740-363-1121
Kurt Larsen 440 POLARIS PKWY STE 400
www.kurtlarsen.com 43082
888-576-7900
Steven Dennis 154 N Chillicothe St
43064
Vin Thibodeau 1474 N. 21St Street
43055
(844) 483-8974

Top Allstate Home Insurance Agents in Pickaway County, OH

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
Shubert & Assoc Llc 3946 North Hampton Drive
43065
Scott A. Panyi 1944 Baltimore Reynoldsburg Road
43068
William Fielder 165 West Main Street 165 West Main Street New\u00a0Albany
43054
Mcrae Ins Agy Inc 1258 Hill Road N
43147-8984
(614) 868-5850
Azita Shirazi 377 E William St
43015-2157
740-362-5500
Kurt Hesser 15 MIDDLE ST
43021
614-761-2825
Jinks Clary 20 E MAPLE ST
43060
937-747-2400
Dempsey Young 999 N 21st St
43055
(740) 366-7391
Timothy Mullins 1730 N Limestone St
45503
Southern Ins Agency 414 E Main St
43130

Top GEICO Home Insurance Agents in Pickaway County, OH

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
Rhonda Evans 2020 Brice Rd Ste 120
43068
(614) 837-6391
Email:rhevans@geico.com

Homeowners Insurance Comparison for the Cheapest Premiums in Pickaway County, OH

Liberty MutualNationwideState Farm
Median Home Value ($) 166,800156,800146,800
Construction year 200920141985
Home Coverage ($) $150000-$175000$150000-$175000$125000-$150000
Total Premium ($) $1290$1125$1159

Pickaway County, OH Multi Policy Discounts by Home Insurance Companies

Home Insurance Company Multi Policy Discount (%)
Liberty Mutual upto 16%
Nationwide upto 10%
Allstate upto 21%
GEICO upto 20%