Check out the most popular Home Insurance agencies & companies in Madison County, OH & compare the best quotes from them.

Get Quotes From The Best & Compare

Top Home Insurance Companies in Madison County, OH

Home Insurance Company A.M. Best Financial Strength Rating Homeowners Insurance Market share
State Farm A 20.9%
Liberty Mutual A 8.64%
Travelers A++ 8%
Erie A+ 5.39%
GEICO A++ 3.2%

Top Liberty Mutual Home Insurance Agents in Madison County, OH

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
Bhavin Patel 2275 Miabrg Cntrvl Rd
45459-3816
937-433-5649
Sean Goral 3600 Main Street
43026
Yolanda Munoz Lutcf 511 Main St
43125
Catherine Driscoll Lutcf 9546 Taylor Rd SW
43068-3228
614-861-7474
Timothy Hanke 5114 Blazer Pkwy
43017
Thomas Bell 5880 Venture Dr
43017
Justin Hampton 2991 W BROAD ST
43204
614-235-5413
John P Mccombs Lutcf 96 E 4TH ST
45601
740-773-1620
Julisa Thomison 620 N MAIN ST
45066
937-748-2651
Dylan Hayes 104 E College Ave
43081
(614) 306-2726

Top Erie Home Insurance Agents in Madison County, OH

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
Reilly Insurance Services 5022 Pine Creek Dr Ste A
www.reillyinsurance.net 43081
(614) 895-5490
Email:reilly.insure@mciworldcom.net
Advantage Insurance Group Llc 3944 N Hampton Dr
43065-8442
614-889-0271
Sekunda Shadle Insurance Agency 4161 N High Street
43214
The George Group Llc 1500 Lake Shore Drive #400
43204
(614) 500-4541
Somonauk Insurance Agency Inc. 6059 Frantz Rd Ste 105
43017
Countryside Insurance Agency Inc 7846 Olentangy River Road
www.countrysideinsinc.com 43235-1354
614-846-2886
Walton-Ebert Agency 242 N Detroit St
45385
Groves Insurance Agency Llc 3986 N Hampton Dr
43065
(614) 734-9880
Douple Agency Inc 582 E Dayton Yellow Springs Rd
45324
(937) 878-0100
Bowers Insurance Agency Inc 1964 N Lakeman Dr Ste D
www.bowersgrp.com 45305-1229
937-848-6000

Top GEICO Home Insurance Agents in Madison County, OH

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
Monica Johnson 5540 FAR HILLS AVE
45429
937-294-1755
Email:mojohnson@geico.com
Rhonda Evans 2020 Brice Rd Ste 120
43068
(614) 837-6391
Email:rhevans@geico.com

Top State Farm Home Insurance Agents in Madison County, OH

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
John Parker 2204 STRINGTOWN RD
www.johnparkeragency.com 43123
614-875-1770
Ann Percy 139 S Sunbury Rd
www.askannpercy.com 43081-9305
614-890-1166
Belinda Barreras-Medrano 300 Richland Rd
www.askbelinda.com 43302-5712
740-389-2555
Kim Lee 348 GRANVILLE ST STE E
www.kimleeinsurance.com 43230
614-536-0370
Shannon Fortune 27 S Liberty Street
www.shannonfortune.com 43065
Rich Sheldon 4030 N Hampton Dr
www.richsheldon.com 43065
(614) 336-8800
Jj Puccio 6050 TAIN DRIVE
www.mystatesboroagent.com 43017
614-789-6800
Rich Ziegler 438 E Wilson Bridge Rd Ste 105
www.richziegler.com 43085
(614) 769-6436
Rhonda Greathouse 3440 S Hamilton Rd
www.rhondagreathouse.net 43232
(614) 864-3882
Jack Mishler Po Box 128
43344

Top Travelers Home Insurance Agents in Madison County, OH

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
Chiman Odhavji Kotecha 2930 Hayden Run Plz
www.insurancediamondbar.com 43235-7261
614-874-2900
Harry Gottlieb & Co Inc 621 Broad St Sw Ste 2E
43062
(740) 964-2494
Email:steve@harrygottlieb.com
Bishop-Lusink Insurance Agency 1245 S Sunbury Rd Ste 200
43081-9444
614-890-5440
Anchor Insurance Services Inc 34 E College Ave
43081-1601
614-882-9414
Mcsweeney & Ricci Insurance 104 Mill St
43230-3034
(614) 471-2366
Email:phimmelman@mcsweeneyricci.com
D G Myers Agency Llc 1165 Clinton Avenue
www.dgmyers.net 43160-1214
740-335-8532
Email:mail@dgmyers.net
Elgin H Lenhardt & Sons 2190 Hewitt Ave
45440
(937) 458-5060
Email:L7448@aol.com
Jl Martin Insurance Agency 1000 GEORGESVILLE RD
43228
614-276-7821
Email:jeannie@jmartinins.com
John P Riley Insurance Agency 39 N MAIN ST STE 201
45644
740-642-3333
Email:RILEY379@AOL.COM
American Advantage-Stoecker Agency 4612 N High St
43214-2002
614-262-1055

Homeowners Insurance Comparison for the Cheapest Premiums in Madison County, OH

TravelersErieLiberty Mutual
Median Home Value ($) 141,030171,030171,030
Construction year 198119452014
Home Coverage ($) $200000-$250000$200000-$250000$300000-$350000
Total Premium ($) $702$1195$914

Madison County, OH Multi Policy Discounts by Home Insurance Companies

Home Insurance Company Multi Policy Discount (%)
Liberty Mutual upto 19%
Erie upto 18%
GEICO upto 17%
Travelers upto 10%