Check out the most popular Home Insurance agencies & companies in Lancaster, OH & compare the best quotes from them.

Get Quotes From The Best & Compare

Top Home Insurance Companies in Lancaster, OH

Home Insurance Company A.M. Best Financial Strength Rating Homeowners Insurance Market share
State Farm A 20.9%
Liberty Mutual A 8.64%
Travelers A++ 8%
Nationwide A+ 7.28%
GEICO A++ 3.2%

Top Nationwide Home Insurance Agents in Lancaster, OH

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
Supplee Insurance Group Inc 6025 Cleveland Ave
43231
Kenneth Ray Henry 39 WEST WINTER ST STE 207
43015
740-369-1040
Butler Insurance Agency Inc 82 Mill St Ste A
43230-3058
614-476-5776
Wade Timothy P Inc 4218 Indianola Ave
43214
Thomas L Harrison Insurance Agency Inc 801 W Cherry St Ste 117
43074
Noltensmeyer Insurance Services Llc 4490 WINCHESTER PIKE
43232
(614) 837-2131
Kenneth Rhodes And Associates Inc. 441 VILLAGE PARK DRIVE
43065
614-433-9930
Kenneth Ray Henry 2815 STRATFORD RD
43015
740-369-9611
Kenneth Ray Henry 163 N SANDUSKY ST STE 204
43015
740-990-7107
Noltensmeyer Ins Serv Llc 3793 BROADWAY
43123
(614) 871-1200

Top GEICO Home Insurance Agents in Lancaster, OH

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
Rhonda Evans 2020 Brice Rd Ste 120
43068
(614) 837-6391
Email:rhevans@geico.com
Jim Irvin 482 HARCOURT RD
43050
740-397-2333
Email:jirvin@geico.com

Top Travelers Home Insurance Agents in Lancaster, OH

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
Rhoe B Henderson Agency Inc 2205 W High St Ste C
www.rhoebhenderson.com 43055
(740) 763-7009
Barrs Insurance Inc 1258 Grandview Ave Ste C
www.barrsinsurance.com 43212-3469
614-486-3276
Valentine Ins Agcy Inc 806 Market St
43701

Email:donn@valentineinsurance.net
Scott Agency Inc 1792 Sawgrass Drive
www.scottagency.net 43068

Email:info@scottagency.net
Lana Yatskina 1580 FISHINGER RD
43221
614-459-1122
Email:lanay@q.com
Anchor Insurance Services Inc 34 E College Ave
43081-1601
614-882-9414
Anco Insurance Bryan-College Station 5540 N Hamilton Rd
43230-1322
614-855-9421
Northwest Consultants Inc 165 W MAIN ST
43054
(614) 939-5471
Alliance Group Of North Carolina Inc 652 W Central Ave Ste 10
www.allianceinsurancenc.com 43015-1440
740-362-5632
Email:troy@agonc.com
Welsh & Parker Insurance 9145 Miller Rd
www.welshparker.com 43031

Top Liberty Mutual Home Insurance Agents in Lancaster, OH

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
Sunny Singh 111 W Johnstown Rd
43230
Timothy Hanke 5114 Blazer Pkwy
43017
Charles R. Longo Jr. 194 W Church St
43147-1213
614-837-6700
Tom Keating Lutcf 700 S High St
43206
(614) 745-8199
Chuck Burland 22 E Water St
45601-2534
740-773-1824
Oscar Quintana 1600 W LANE AVE STE 200
43221
614-453-4400
Catherine Driscoll Lutcf 9546 Taylor Rd SW
43068-3228
614-861-7474
Justin Hampton 2991 W BROAD ST
43204
614-235-5413
John P Mccombs Lutcf 96 E 4TH ST
45601
740-773-1620
Blake Prow 2844 Johnstown Rd
43219-1772
614-471-5557

Top State Farm Home Insurance Agents in Lancaster, OH

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
Yolanda Vasquez 159 S Hamilton Rd
www.yolandavasquez.com 43213
Greg Hicks 1956 East Pike
www.greghicks.net 43701
(740) 455-6156
Danny Thomas 2986 North High Street
www.dannymthomas.net 43202-1136
614-262-6700
Darrell Tucker 716 Arch Street
43701-5702
740-455-6319
Barney J Belleci 2810 Maple Ave Ste B
43701-1751
740-454-6297
Jim Hussey 12165 LANCASTER ST
www.husseyins.com 43046
740-467-2040
Dan Arnold 2525 Bell Street
43701-1803
740-455-9029
Kim Lau-Darnell 5310 E MAIN ST 201
www.insurewithkim.com 43213
614-577-9104
Vic Everett 2409 Stratford Rd
43015
Matt Berquam Po Box 149
43731

Homeowners Insurance Comparison for the Cheapest Premiums in Lancaster, OH

Liberty MutualGEICOState Farm
Median Home Value ($) 106,290126,290116,290
Construction year 200120071969
Home Coverage ($) $100000-$125000$100000-$125000$100000-$125000
Total Premium ($) $919$908$971

Lancaster, OH Multi Policy Discounts by Home Insurance Companies

Home Insurance Company Multi Policy Discount (%)
Nationwide upto 8%
GEICO upto 24%
Travelers upto 11%
Liberty Mutual upto 17%