Check out the most popular Home Insurance agencies & companies in Columbus, OH & compare the best quotes from them.
| Home Insurance Company | A.M. Best Financial Strength Rating | Homeowners Insurance Market share |
|---|---|---|
| State Farm | A | 20.9% |
| Allstate | A+ | 10.89% |
| Travelers | A++ | 8% |
| Nationwide | A+ | 7.28% |
| GEICO | A++ | 3.2% |
| Homeowners Insurance Agents | Agent Address | Contact Details | |
|---|---|---|---|
| John P. Schwarzel | 328 E MAIN ST 43113 |
740-474-2153 | |
| Dempsey Young | 999 N 21st St 43055 |
(740) 366-7391 | |
| Benjamin Farwell | 700 N Main St 43050-1720 |
740-392-3991 | |
| Marvin Waldrep | 3730 Ridge Mill Dr 43026-7987 |
(614) 529-8900 | |
| Commonwealth Ins Ag | 6075 Chandler Ct 43082-9050 |
614-890-2555 | |
| Kurt Hesser | 15 MIDDLE ST 43021 |
614-761-2825 | |
| Monica Miller | 115 N PROSPECT ST 43023 |
(740) 587-7523 | |
| J L Massie Ins Agy | 7100 N HIGH ST STE 300 43085 |
614-848-3000 | |
| Southern Ins Agency | 414 E Main St 43130 |
||
| Stephen Ratkewitch | 555 Metro Pl N Ste 200 43017 |
| Homeowners Insurance Agents | Agent Address | Contact Details | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Jim Irvin | 482 HARCOURT RD 43050 |
740-397-2333 Email:jirvin@geico.com |
|
| Rhonda Evans | 2020 Brice Rd Ste 120 43068 |
(614) 837-6391 Email:rhevans@geico.com |
| Homeowners Insurance Agents | Agent Address | Contact Details | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Davidson Insurance Agency | 6477 N Hamilton Rd www.davidsonagency.com 43081 |
(614) 299-7000 Email:DIA@DavidsonAgency.com |
|
| Tarpey Insurance Group Inc | 7393 Linden Ln 43016 |
Email:steve@tarpeyinsurance.com |
|
| Mcsweeney & Ricci Insurance Agency Inc | 2690 East Main St www.mcsewwneyricci.com 43209-8024 |
(614) 235-5413 | |
| Safeguard Ins Group Inc | 108 E Main Street 43731 |
||
| Anne Marie Northup | 7368 E Broad St 43004-9627 |
614-866-0856 | |
| Dickerson Agency Inc | 1000 High St Ste E www.dickersonagency.com 43085 |
(614) 349-4499 Email:Warren@DickersonAgency.com |
|
| Collinsworth Alter Lambert Llc | 21 W Broad St Ste 100 raisingyourexpectations.com 43215-4168 |
614-461-7833 Email:dlambert@calllc.com |
|
| Tianliang Li | 119 Dillmont Dr Ste 105 43235 |
||
| Walsh Carter & Assoc Ins Services Llc | 12927 Stonecreek Dr www.walshcarter.com 43147 |
||
| The Ridge Agency | 1721 Bethel Rd 43220 |
| Homeowners Insurance Agents | Agent Address | Contact Details | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Max Garnett | 137 E Main St www.maxgarnett.net 43113-1725 |
(740) 474-2287 | |
| Tommy Skinner | 114 W Church St www.tommyskinneragency.com 43302 |
||
| Rich Walls | 100 E Campus View Blvd Ste 360 43235 |
(614) 584-1683 | |
| Jim Hummel | 1287 W MAIN ST 43055 |
740-344-2141 | |
| Amber Chow | 12979 Stonecreek Dr www.amberchow.com 43147-8424 |
614-861-6446 | |
| Tom Shea | 3083 Columbus Street Grove\u00a0City 43123 |
||
| Ann Dunham | 425 W Schrock Rd Ste 101 www.anndunham.com 43081-8720 |
614-898-9977 | |
| Matt Mangold | 106 S Walnut St 45601-3220 |
(740) 774-1225 | |
| Jac Clutter | Po Box 1207 43017 |
||
| Marvis Simpson | 3730 Ridge Mill Dr. www.marvissimpson.net 43026-7987 |
(614) 345-0171 |
| Homeowners Insurance Agents | Agent Address | Contact Details | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Marsh Insurance & Financial Inc. | 711 W Fair Ave 43130-2374 |
(740) 653-7111 | |
| Max Eugene Olson | 3079 W Broad St 43204 |
(614) 278-0278 | |
| Max Eugene Olson | 888 N Court St 43113-1259 |
(740) 474-1991 | |
| The Pizzichillo Agency Inc | 90 E Wilson Bridge Rd Fl 1 43085 |
||
| Triumph Insurance Agency Llc | 1400 Haft Dr 43068 |
||
| Jim Jackson | 73 SOUTH MAIN ST 43031 |
740-966-3180 | |
| Rhonda D Womack | 333 W Coshocton St Ste A 43031 |
(740) 318-4840 | |
| H.P. Lucas Inc. | 51 N Sandusky St 43015 |
(740) 369-2886 | |
| Alan Murray Rubin | 2810 London Groveport Rd 43123-9590 |
614-539-3333 | |
| Kenneth Rhodes And Associates Inc. | 50 E OLENTANGY ST STE 320C 43065 |
614-602-5770 |
| Nationwide | GEICO | Allstate | |
| Median Home Value ($) | 132,850 | 132,850 | 122,850 |
| Construction year | 1995 | 1965 | 1947 |
| Home Coverage ($) | $125000-$150000 | $175000-$200000 | $100000-$125000 |
| Total Premium ($) | $1225 | $881 | $1129 |
| Home Insurance Company | Multi Policy Discount (%) |
|---|---|
| Allstate | upto 23% |
| GEICO | upto 22% |
| Travelers | upto 8% |
| Nationwide | upto 11% |